Ethics and Leadership: How Top Leaders Make Better Decisions

Ethics and Leadership Don’t Fail. Execution Does.

Only 55% of employees strongly agree that their organisation has high ethical standards, according to data from the 2023–2024 Global Business Ethics Survey. That number made me pause. Because if you ask most companies, they’ll say ethics and leadership are a priority. They have values on the wall. They run training sessions. They talk about integrity in every town hall.

So what’s going wrong?

Here’s the uncomfortable part. I don’t think companies lack conversations about ethics and leadership. I think they lack real follow-through when it actually matters.

We’ve turned ethics and leadership into something soft. Something safe. Something that sounds good in presentations but quietly disappears the moment there’s pressure, deadlines, or money on the line.

And that’s exactly when it’s supposed to show up. In real life, ethics and leadership are not about being a “good person.”

It’s about what you do when:

• The top performer is toxic but brings in revenue.
• The fastest decision is not the fairest one.
• Speaking up might actually cost you something.

That’s where most leaders fail. Not because they don’t know what’s right, but because the system around them quietly rewards the wrong thing.

In this article, we’re going to look at what great leaders are actually doing differently when it comes to ethics and leadership. Not theory. Not generic advice. Real shifts that make it part of everyday work, not just something we talk about.

And more importantly, how you can actually apply these principles of ethics and leadership in your own team without needing a full company overhaul.

The Hidden Gap in Ethics and Leadership (Even in “Good” Companies)

Most companies don’t have an ethical leadership problem on paper. They have corporate values and ethics policies. They talk about doing the right thing. But when you look at what actually happens day to day, it’s a different story.

• A top performer behaves badly but still gets rewarded.
• A rushed decision ignores long-term impact because targets matter more.
• Someone notices something off … but says nothing.

This is where ethical leadership quietly breaks down. Not because people don’t care, but because the way work is structured makes it hard to act ethically in real moments. And this isn’t just a feeling. A PwC report on workplace ethics found that pressure to meet targets is one of the main reasons employees act unethically.

So if we’re serious about ethical leadership, we need to look beyond values and start looking at what actually drives behaviour.

1. The “Nice Leader” Trap

One of the biggest misconceptions is that ethical leadership means being nice.

So leaders avoid difficult conversations. They let small issues slide. They don’t challenge behaviour early because they don’t want to create tension or affect team spirit. At first, it feels harmless. But over time, it creates a pattern. Because when behaviour isn’t addressed, it becomes accepted.

Research from Harvard Business Review on leadership avoidance of workplace misconduct shows that leaders often avoid addressing misconduct because they fear damaging relationships or team morale. But that avoidance is exactly what allows problems to grow.

This is where ethical leadership starts to fail quietly. Because ethical leadership is not about keeping people comfortable, it’s about being clear when something is not okay.

What to do instead:

• Address issues early, before they become patterns
• Be specific about behaviour, not the person
• Use simple, direct language: “This result is strong, but how we got there doesn’t align with how we work.”

Do Your Learners Return from Training and Do Nothing Differently?

Our Sticky Learning ® method is 7x more effective than 1-day training courses. Plus, we deliver a Chain of Evidence report proving your Return on Investment. Discover Soft Skills Training that changes behaviours long-term.

Get Started Now

2. Values Without Consequences

Even in companies that care about ethics and leadership, there’s often a gap between what is said and what is enforced.

You’ll hear things like:

• “We value integrity.”
• “We put people first.”

But when those values are tested, the response is often inconsistent. And employees notice that fast.

If someone delivers results but ignores those values and still gets rewarded, the real message becomes clear. Results matter more. That’s why ethics and leadership cannot live in statements alone. It has to show up in decisions.

So the issue isn’t awareness of ethics and leadership.

It’s reinforcement.

What to do instead:

• Tie promotions and rewards behaviour, not just outcomes
• Ask in reviews: “How were these results achieved?”
• Make value-based decisions visible: “We made this call because it aligns with our values.”

When consequences are clear, ethical leadership becomes real.

3. Systems Quietly Reward the Wrong Behaviour

This is the part most people don’t expect. Even good people make bad decisions in the wrong system.

If a company has an employee reward system for :

• Speed over accuracy
• Results overbehaviour
• Silence over speaking up

Then, ethical leadership will always struggle.

And this isn’t just theory. Research from MIT Sloan Management Review found that toxic workplace culture is one of the strongest predictors of unethical behaviour.

So the problem is not just individuals. It’s the environment they operate in. This is where ethical leadership needs to evolve.

Not just better leaders, but better systems.

What to do instead :

• Audit what actually gets rewarded in your team
• Create space for challenge in meetings: “What are we missing?”
• Trabehaviourior signals, not just performance

Because when the system supports ethical leadership, people don’t have to choose between doing well and doing right.

What Great Leaders Are Doing Differently

If ethics and leadership fail in the small moments, then this is exactly where great leaders stand out. Not by being “more ethical” in theory, but by changing how decisions actually happen. And when you look closely, the difference is simple.

They don’t rely on values alone. They make ethics and leadership something people can see, feel, and act on every day.

1- They Make Ethical Trade-Offs Visible (Instead of Pretending Everything Is a Win-Win)

One of the biggest differences you notice when ethics and leadership are strong is honesty. Not the kind you write in a mission statement. The kind you say out loud when a decision is uncomfortable.

Take Patagonia.

They didn’t just position themselves as a sustainable brand. They made decisions that clearly showed what they were willing to give up.

In one of their most well-known campaigns, they literally told customers: “Don’t buy this jacket.” The idea was simple. Reduce overconsumption, even if it hurts sales in the short term.

But it didn’t stop there. They’ve invested heavily in repairing products, reselling used items, and building supply chains that are more expensive but more aligned with ethics and leadership. What’s interesting is not just the decision. It’s how visible they made it.

Customers, employees, and even competitors could see the trade-off: We are choosing long-term impact over short-term profit.

And that visibility builds trust in a way vague values never can. I honestly think this is where most companies struggle. They want to look perfect instead of being clear about what they’re choosing.

What you can do:

Start bringing ethics and leadership into the actual decision conversation, not just the outcome.

In your next team discussion, try this structure:

• “Here are our options.”
• “Here’s the benefit of each.”
• “Here’s the ethical risk or downside of each.”

Then say it clearly: “We’re choosing this option, and here’s the trade-off we’re accepting.”

Even in a small team, this shifts how people think about ethics and leadership. Decisions stop feeling neutral. People start understanding the reasoning behind them. And over time, that’s how it becomes part of how your team actually operates.

2. They Redefine Performance, Behaviour Actually Matters

Here’s where ethical leadership usually breaks. A company says behaviour matters. But when it’s time to reward people, results still win.

So employees adapt. They focus on outcomes, even if it means cutting corners. The companies that get this right don’t just say behaviour matters. They build it into performance management systems and how employee performance is evaluated.

Take Salesforce.

They’ve made equality and ethical leadership part of how leaders are evaluated. Managers are expected to build inclusive teams, treat people fairly, and actively support others’ growth.

And when they found pay gaps across employees, they didn’t just acknowledge it. They spent millions adjusting salaries to correct it. That’s a strong signal.

Not because of the statement, but because of the action: Ethical leadership is tied to real decisions, not just language.

What makes this powerful is consistency. When employees see that behaviour affects promotions, pay, and recognition, they adjust what they prioritise.

What you can do :

You don’t need a full HR system to start building stronger ethics and leadership.

• Start small and build it into what you already do:

In performance reviews, add one simple section: “How were these results achieved?”

• Be specific when giving feedback:

Instead of: “Great job.”

Say: “You handled that situation fairly and included others in the decision. That reflects strong ethics and leadership.”

• Watch for your own bias as a leader:

Ask yourself: “Am I excusing this behaviour because the results are good?”

Even just catching that once changes how you lead. Ethics and leadership become real when people realise that how they work is just as important as what they deliver.

3. They Turn Speaking Up Into a Normal Part of Work (Not a Risky Move)

In most workplaces, people already know when something feels off. The problem is not awareness. It’s hesitation.

They think:

• “Maybe it’s not my place.”
• “What if I’m wrong?”
• “What if this backfires?”

And that hesitation is where ethical leadership starts to collapse. Because silence protects problems.

What’s interesting about Bridgewater Associates is not that they encourage feedback. A lot of companies say that.

It’s how far they go to normalise it. They call it “Radical Truth and Radical Transparency.” Meetings are recorded. Decisions are challenged openly. Employees are expected to question ideas, regardless of seniority.

Now, I don’t think every company should copy that model exactly. It can be intense. But it highlights something important.

Ethical leadership doesn’t grow in comfortable silence. It grows in environments where questioning is expected.

And as Amy Edmondson, an American scholar, puts it:

“If people are afraid to speak up, errors multiply.”

That applies to ethics just as much as performance.

What you can do:

You don’t need radical transparency to start. You just need consistency. Try this in your next few meetings:

• Add a pause before final decisions: “Before we move on, is there anything we’re missing?”
• Rotate responsibility: Assign one person to challenge the idea at each meeting on purpose.
• Most importantly, control your reaction. When someone speaks up, respond like this: “That’s helpful, I’m glad you said that.”

That one response determines whether they’ll speak up again. Ethical leadership is not built by telling people to speak up. It’s built by how you respond when they do.

4. They Design Systems That Make Ethical Leadership Easier

This is the biggest shift, and honestly, the most overlooked. Most companies expect people to make the right decisions, even when the system makes it difficult. But strong ethical leadership flips that.

It asks: How do we make the right decision easier?

A good example is Airbnb.

After facing serious concerns about discrimination on the platform in 2016, they didn’t just release a statement and move on. They changed how the system works.

They introduced anti-discrimination commitments that users had to agree to. They adjusted booking flows. They created clearer policies and accountability mechanisms.

In other words, they didn’t just ask people to behave better. They made it harder not to. That’s a different level of ethical leadership. Because it doesn’t rely on individual courage. It relies on design.

What you can do:

Look at your own team or workflow and ask: “Where are people forced to choose between doing what’s right and doing what’s easy?”

Then fix that point.

For example:

• If people rush decisions → build in a short review step
• If concerns are ignored → create a simple, safe way to raise them
• If accountability is unclear → define who owns what, clearly

You don’t need a big system. Even small process changes can shift behaviour.

Because once the system supports ethical leadership, people don’t have to fight it.

How to Apply Ethical Leadership in Your Workplace

Ethical leadership is not built through big changes. It is built through small, repeatable actions inside daily work.

The goal is simple: Make ethical leadership part of how decisions are made, how people are evaluated, and how teams operate.

Here is a system you can apply immediately.

Step 1: Add a Decision Filter to Important Choices

Most ethical mistakes happen because decisions are made too quickly.

You don’t need to slow everything down. You just need a bit of structure to support better ethics and leadership in important decisions.

Use this simple filter:

1. Who benefits from this decision
2. Who could be negatively affected
3. What risk are we accepting
4. Would we be comfortable explaining this publicly

This kind of pause is where ethics and leadership actually show up in practice, not just in theory.

How to apply:

• Use this only for key decisions, not every small task
• Say the answers out loud in meetings
• Write them briefly if the decision is high-impact

This creates clarity and forces the team to think beyond speed and results.

Step 2: Make Trade-Offs Clear in Every Decision

Every decision has a cost. Ethical leadership means being clear about it.

Instead of presenting decisions as fully positive, always include what is being sacrificed.

How to apply:

• When presenting options, include one benefit and one risk for each
• State the final decision clearly, including what you are accepting

For example, say:

“We are choosing this option because it is faster, but it reduces review time, so we need to monitor quality closely.”

This builds accountability and prevents hidden risks.

Step 3: Add Behaviour to Performance Reviews

If behaviour is not measured, it will be ignored. Ethical leadership becomes real when behaviour affects feedback, promotions, and recognition.

How to apply:

Add one section in reviews focused on behaviour. Use these three questions:

1. How were the results achieved?
2. Did this person support or harm the team?
3. Did they raise concerns when needed?

Give specific feedback, not general comments, and address issues early, not only at formal reviews.

Important rule:

Do not ignore toxic behaviour because of strong results. Address it clearly and early.

Step 4: Build a Simple Speak-Up Routine

Telling people to speak up is not enough. You need to make it part of how meetings work.

How to apply:

Before finalising decisions, ask: “What are we missing?”

• Pause and allow time for responses
• Rotate responsibility: Assign one person to question the decision
• After meetings, allow private feedback through direct messages or short check-ins

Most important:

Your reaction matters. When someone raises a concern:

1. Acknowledge it
2. Explore it briefly
3. Do not dismiss it immediately

This builds consistency and makes speaking up normal.

Step 5: Identify and Fix One System Issue

Ethical leadership often fails because systems push people toward the wrong behaviour. Instead of trying to fix everything, focus on one issue.

How to apply:

Look for patterns:

• Where are mistakes repeated
• Where are concerns ignored
• Where do people feel pressure to rush or cut corners

Fix one point in the process:

• Add a short review step
• Define clear ownership
• Add a required risk check before decisions

Small system changes have a strong impact on behaviour.

Step 6: Reinforce Ethical Leadership Weekly

If ethical leadership is not visible, it fades. You need to reinforce it regularly in small ways.

How to apply:

• In team meetings, highlight one good decision or behaviour
• Acknowledge actions that reflect fairness, transparency, or accountability
• Share short reflections: What worked well and what could improve

This takes little time but builds consistency.

Step 7: Define Clear Non-Negotiables

Teams need clarity on what is not acceptable. Vague values are not enough.

How to apply:

1. Define two to three clear boundaries, for example:

• No misleading information
• No ignoring concerns
• No disrespectful behavior

2. Communicate them clearly

3. Act immediately if they are crossed

What Ethical Leadership Looks Like in Real Life

1. A manager sits down with their top performer and is clear, not vague.

“Your results are strong, but I’ve had feedback about how you’re speaking to the team. This needs to change. Going forward, how you work with people will be part of how we evaluate your performance.”

Then they follow up on it in the next review. Not just a conversation, but a standard.

2. A team is ready to launch, but there’s a known issue that could affect users. 

Instead of pushing through to hit the deadline, they pause. They agree on what needs fixing, reset expectations, and communicate the delay early rather than explaining a problem later.

3. A leader realises that a decision they made had a negative impact.

In the next meeting, they say, “We missed this risk when we made that call. That’s on me. Here’s what we’re changing so it doesn’t happen again.”

Then they adjust the process, not just the message.

Conclusion: Ethical Leadership Is What You Do

Ethics and leadership are not about what you say. Most leaders already know the right thing to do.

The difference is in what actually happens day to day. It shows up in decisions, in conversations, and in what you choose to reward or ignore. That is where ethics and leadership either become real or disappear.

If they only exist in values or statements, they do not change anything. Ethics and leadership are not one big moment. They are a pattern built over time. And people always notice the pattern.